Log in

04 February 2010 @ 12:23 am
Rnd2-Chal10: Voting  
PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU READ THE RULES CAREFULLY. If you don't follow the rules, I will NOT count your vote. Since this is the final challenge, we're going to be voting differently, so it's very important that you read the rules.

- Voting will last until February 10th at 8pm EST. You do not need to be a participant to vote.
- Vote for the icon that you think is the BEST for each of the three parts. You are NOT voting somebody off this time. You are not required to give reasons for your votes, but they are always appreciated. Remember, these votes will determine the winner of this round. Make sure you're voting for the icons that you legitimately think are the BEST.
- If you are one of the final three, you are not allowed to vote for this challenge.
- The person with the most votes will be the winner of Round Two of startrek_lims!

Please use the form:

the participants were given a screencap to icon

1 2 3

the participants had to make a promo banner


this was a free-for-all

1 2 3

dream a little bigger, darling.: [ST XI] Gailabeth_soprano on February 4th, 2010 07:15 am (UTC)
Part One:

Part Two:

Part Three:
eva: stock; butterflyakemilove on February 8th, 2010 08:28 am (UTC)
Part One:
#01 - Nice crop and colouring.

Part Two:
#01 - Great shape and composition.

Part Three:
#02 - Very pretty, soft colouring.
the ineffableaquietmess on February 8th, 2010 07:41 pm (UTC)
Part One:
#03 - The cropping is good, the coloring nice - overall a very good icon

Part Two:
#01 - Text and crop work really good together, also the coloring is great and very simple. I like it.

Part Three:
#03 - The blending is well done imo and the text suit it
sith_romantic on February 10th, 2010 04:49 pm (UTC)
Part One:
#3 - I really like the sharpening on your icon that makes visible the shine of his eyes. The colouring is also nice.

Part Two:
#1 - Great idea and text. Picture is simple and clear, nice.

Part Three:
#3 - Skilled use of the black & white style and also composition is beautiful.